Italy Passes New Law Against Antisemitism
Listen to the story
Italy's Chamber of Deputies has approved a new bill against antisemitism, turning it into law with 147 votes in favour, according to Ansa. The measure defines antisemitism and aims to strengthen legal protections against discrimination targeting Jewish people.
The vote, however, exposed deep divisions across the political spectrum. Both the Five Star Movement (M5s) and the left-wing alliance Avs (Alleanza Verdi e Sinistra) voted against the bill, signalling opposition from parts of the opposition and the left.
Perhaps more significantly, the law also triggered an internal rift within the centre-left Democratic Party (Pd). A faction of so-called reformists broke ranks with the party's official stance, reflecting the broader tension the bill has created across the Italian left.
At the heart of the controversy lies a contested question: can criticism of Israel's government or policies be classified as antisemitic? This definitional dispute has split opinion among left-leaning lawmakers and commentators, some of whom argue that conflating criticism of Israeli state actions with hatred of Jewish people risks silencing legitimate political debate, while others contend that certain forms of criticism can mask or enable antisemitic sentiment.
The parliamentary session was further marked by a heated exchange involving a deputy from the Futuro Nazionale party, who delivered a pointed attack against communist partisans โ the armed resistance fighters who opposed fascist and Nazi forces during the Second World War โ branding them 'cowards'. The remark drew a response from Pd politician Giorgio Cuperlo, although the available reporting does not detail the full content of his reply.
The episode illustrates how a law intended to combat antisemitism has become entangled with broader ideological fault lines in Italian politics, touching on historical memory, party unity, and the limits of acceptable political speech regarding Israel. The debate is likely to continue as the law moves toward implementation and as political factions continue to negotiate its interpretation.
Vocabulary7 words
- bill
- a plan for a new law before it is officially passed
- rift
- a serious split or disagreement inside a group
- reformists
- members of a group who want to change its direction
- deputy
- an elected member of the lower house of parliament
- partisans
- resistance fighters who opposed enemy forces, especially in war
- antisemitism
- hatred or unfair treatment directed at Jewish people
- conflating
- wrongly treating two different things as if they are the same
Quiz
Answer key
1. The antisemitism bill was approved and became law 2. Whether criticism of Israel can count as antisemitism 3. False
โ Nice work on the quiz!
Keep the momentum going โ book a live English lesson with a Preply tutor.
Discussion questions
- What challenges arise when lawmakers try to define antisemitism in legislation?
- Why might criticism of a government's foreign policy be difficult to separate from prejudice against a nation's people?
- How does historical memory, such as the role of wartime partisans, continue to influence political debate today?
- What are the risks and benefits of passing laws that define specific forms of hatred or discrimination?

